| Benford Chart for NC 10K Filed 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Total numbers found: 1,032 Recent share count: 5,731,447 (5's column) ■ = Typical range across full coverage universe | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| # of Numbers Found in Filing | |||
|
On this page of Benford's Law Stocks.com we present our study of NACCO INDUSTRIES INC — ticker symbol NC. SEC filings have been screened by our Benford's Law software, for quarterly 10Q and annual 10K filings from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025
for NACCO INDUSTRIES INC under CIK number 0000789933.
For filings made in XBRL (eXtensible
Business Reporting Language) format, our algorithm extracts all "tagged" numbers presented by the company; for any non-XBRL
filings our algorithm uses its own interal set of rules to extract what it believes to be numbers as found throughout the filings. The format
found for each filing is presented below together with the results for NC, with the percentage of found numbers beginning with each digit
(1's, 2's, 3's, 4's, 5's, 6's, 7's, 8's, and 9's) charted against the "normal" range observed throughout our coverage universe, as
well as the "normal" range for NACCO INDUSTRIES INC based on the past NC filings our system processed in the past.
| Benford's Law Stocks Score for NC = 74 | ||
Starting from a possible score of 100, we made the following score deductions: • We deducted point upon observing the 1's percentage was below the typical coverage universe range. • We deducted point upon observing the 1's percentage was below the company's typical historical range. • The 5's percentage was higher than the 4's percentage, increasing the penalty multiplier. • However, because we observed that the company's shares outstanding count begins with the digit 5, we canceled the penalty multiplier. • We deducted point upon observing the 5's percentage was above the typical coverage universe range. • We deducted points upon observing the 6's percentage was above the typical coverage universe range. • We deducted points upon observing the 6's percentage was above the company's typical historical range. • We deducted points upon observing the 7's percentage was above the typical coverage universe range. • The 9's percentage was higher than the 8's percentage, increasing the penalty multiplier. • We deducted points (includes the impact of penalty multiplier) upon observing the 9's percentage was above the typical coverage universe range. • We deducted points (includes the impact of penalty multiplier) upon observing the 9's percentage was above the company's typical historical range. |
| NC's Score Vs. Typical Stock | |||
|
Check our work! We provide our NACCO INDUSTRIES INC Benford's Law analysis for informational purposes only, and our software should be expected to
make mistakes and contain errors (nothing you see on this website should be relied upon for any decision-making without first repeating
the analysis yourself independently), and so below we present to you all of the numbers our system detected, for the NC filing
above. This way, you can open the filing on your own and compare what you see below against what you yourself find. This can also
be helpful for exploring any columns in particular that caught your eye.
| 1's | 2's | 3's |
|---|---|---|
| We found 262 numbers that start with the digit 1. Here they are: 117,744,151 1,565,359 14,591 13,612 134,722 1,805 1,958 1,398 14,159 18,134 14,641 15,081 14,137 12,371 18,663 17,208 19,147 17,721 16,702 1,826 10,000 13,114 17,317 12,114 157,368 1 1 1,565,359 1,565,819 1,566 1,566 10,052 1,517 11,725 12,971 1,904 1,955 148 14,996 1,247 16,556 139 146 10,000 1,468 12,276 110,748 1,566 191 1,398 1,398 1,566 164 1,566 10,052 13.6 19.1 15.7 13.7 198.4 14.2 1.8 162,670 120,649 110,000 150,000 175,000 100 1,603 1.3 1.0 1.3 1.1 1.4 119,600 17,707 171,202 131,521 1,470 12,277 1 1.0 1.5 198,390 17,542 1,920 1,920 1,048 1,900 1,358 1,346 1,717 19,569 1,510 130 19,989 100 1.9 12.3 11.2 10,000 13,953 169,102 115,120 105,120 1,696 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.10 18.8 18,663 18,663 18,663 18,663 17,208 17,208 17,208 17,208 1.5 1.6 13.6 107 1,973 1,485 1 1,712 1,801 1,822 1,822 1,831 1,536 1,536 14,309 14,405 12 11,015 1,823 1.6 1.5 1,612 1,373 16,467 144 1,517 1.4 1.0 14.9 13,473 1,071 109 1 11.5 1,252 12,371 14,816 14,819 12,565 11,672 11,783 1,209 10,633 10,047 14,641 15,081 15,584 14,610 16,526 14,757 1 1.8 1.8 1,360 1,639 1,641 1,815 1,815 1,360 1,639 1,571 1,771 1,571 1,771 12,072 11,379 10,860 100.0 10.0 181 152 173 118 179 1,579 1,551 173 195 1,418 1,579 1,418 1,579 169 183 1,249 1,396 1,418 1,579 123 173 182 185 174 166 1,462 11 119,600 17,707 108,760 110,821 15,323 1,065 134,722 19,418 12 100 1,079 15,492 17,569 1,092 100 14.1 12.4 145,655 124,387 158,591 161,606 16,720 16,179 135,830 14,005 1,233 105,479 15,687 1,843,911 126,724 1,914 10,017 12,534 135,830 1 119,534 122,286 116,526 11,312 18,426 11,419 16,773 11,783 111 11,672 11,809 11,783 | We found 169 numbers that start with the digit 2. Here they are: 237,708 214,794 207,952 200,203 29,756 2,998 221 2,460 2,381 2,059 24,571 205 2,118 24 27,639 264,738 231,998 259,457 223,902 2,800 25,768 21,675 22,663 25,335 22,003 226,740 28,672 24,652 29,387 21,114 221 2,519 27,250 236 22,289 2,415 25,639 23,706 2,118 2,118 28,672 2.5 250,000 2,789 2,597 237,708 214,794 237,708 214,794 212 2.4 27,076 23,784 228,256 259,457 223,902 24.1 26.4 28,460 2,170 2,530 29,538 2.2 29,514 25,956 22,003 2.4 200.0 2.50 27.2 2.75 21.8 2.0 27 28 2,191 28 2,769 2,802 2,441 2,474 21 2,509 25 25,000,000 2,488,013 2,335,178 20.0 2,520 290 2 21,114 24,571 2,273 24,571 24.6 23,731 23,607 2.8 2 2,751 270 2,560 270 28,357 2,261 2,610 2,614 26,680 28,357 26,680 28,357 258 2,452 2,610 2,614 28,251 2,869 2,724 2,750 2,631 2,575 2,514 2,435 23,765 28,028 29,866 223 28,251 229 29 24 22 2,789 2,597 237,708 214,794 2,801 2,497 207,952 200,203 2 25,699 23,668 24,311 28,927 23,317 21,461 24,652 29,387 27,491,840 27,627,670 23,596,110 26,420 23,622,530 23,622,530 29,268 236,491 27,627,670 26,420 2,208 27,902 25,739 27,487 26,481 20,713 2.13 2.64 26 | We found 132 numbers that start with the digit 3. Here they are: 35,705 3,585 345 3,985 33,646 33,741 39,587 33,741 39,587 308 398 33,343 37,429 3,953 39,780 39,499 34,340 373,363 355,873 382,340 33,741 39,587 3,971 3,148 36,714 3,464 3,574 3,103 36,727 3,012 3,103 39,587 39,587 355,873 382,340 317 33,741 33,741 308 308 34,340 373,363 36.7 3.6 3.3 35,965 3.5 3.5 34,579 32,985 37,429 3,712 313 3,500 313 394 3,649 317,933 325,655 3.0 3,528 3,063 33,044 3 35,956 35,956 3,130 30.9 3 35.3 35.8 3,214 33 33 3,940 3,940 3,294 316,950 33,637 33,646 3,405 342 3,457 33,646 3,455 3,512 3 38.3 33.6 3 38.3 32.0 3,630 3,319 35,573 3,478 31,722 30,128 34,485 30,128 3,538 3,787 3 30,128 321 3.6 3.6 34,579 32,985 3,969 30,358 3,348 35,705 30,556 36,073 38,881 3,067 3,309 30,280 380,650 3,720 384,370 384,370 32,077 3,720 38 3,322 3,222 30,280 33,308 32,580 33,521 |
| 4's | 5's | 6's |
|---|---|---|
| We found 81 numbers that start with the digit 4. Here they are: 49,994 4,428 4.58 4.55 417 40,228 49,706 4,179 4,787 404,947 45,408 4,914 4,209 404,924 426,966 4,966 404,947 43.4 4.5 4.1 4.1 44,731 4.7 49,706 484 457,847 452,158 46,002 4,040 49,527 4,179 4,152 40 4.00 4.15 4.4 4 47,095 43,872 48 4.58 4.55 4,647 4,392 4,683 4.0 4.0 4,880 41,083 47 427 4,651 475 456 4,651 4.98 4.98 4.75 4.75 44 49 44 49 416 413 40 44,633 49,994 4,273 49,994 49,284 43,714 48.8 45.8 443,650 473,930 498,627 44,514 473,930 42,380 48,410 | We found 105 numbers that start with the digit 5. Here they are: 5,866,937 57,476 531 5,146 5,566 5,979 5.29 5.29 5,793 5,475 539,708 5,183 5,795 5,730,470 5,882,845 5,730 5,883 539,708 505 5,832 5,157 5,146 54,490 54,706 561 5,232 5,783 5,157 5,883 5,668 5,832 5,730 5.2 53,748 5,119 5 53,216 58,353 5,475 5 52,613 51 5.0 5.3 5.12 5.50 5.1 57 572 5,808 5,566 5.29 5.29 5.2 556 50,214 56,164 5,396 5.39 5.49 5.02 5.04 5.02 5.04 5.36 5.40 5.00 51 58 58 51 58 58 5,624 515 510 528 586 5.26 5.29 50 50 542 582 5,234 51,821 5,010 5,361 57,476 5,772 559 55,419 579 5.5 5.0 542,643 56,831 52,428 51,971 5,237 534 53,646 522 5,867 53,646 | We found 98 numbers that start with the digit 6. Here they are: 69,754 65,616 65,887 65,139 6,081 64,158 615 641 6,466 6,006 631,687 64,888 69,986 6,120 631,687 619 65,887 60,000 624 6,624 6,452 6,452 6,452 6,624 6,624 65.9 6 6 63.9 6.5 65.9 616,681 68,611 66,506 67,532 69,148 68,150 65.9 6,006 65.9 6,115 6.4 6.6 6.2 6.06 65.9 65.9 60.8 61 6,756,176 64,077 64,158 64,158 64.2 6,029 6,489 6,378 61,886 67,947 6 6,148 6,148 632 636 6,068 6 6.50 6.25 6.50 6 6 6 68,611 6,252 647 65,139 6,609 610,734 60,256 63,646 69,148 68,150 6,061 63,087 64,841 620,790 695,190 656,370 665,390 665,390 63,441 695,190 69,716 68,119 61,278 61,278 61,206 61,278 |
| 7's | 8's | 9's |
|---|---|---|
| We found 74 numbers that start with the digit 7. Here they are: 70,137 7,363 7,478 7,411 7,478 706 79 72,833 7,860 77,000 7,996 70,000 794 7,514 713 71,292 72,833 79 79 706 706 7 7.0 7 77,000 7.5 70,766 78,725 78,194 7,075 79 70,000 72,925 70.0 7.7 7.0 79 7 7 786 7,363 7,478 7,411 7,478 7,066 796 701 7,083 7,866 7,429 752 7.00 7 75 77 75 78 75 7 75 77 7 79,375 71,342 70,137 798,043 772,003 74,400 7,040,710 722,300 74,400 74,891 75.48 78.22 | We found 53 numbers that start with the digit 8. Here they are: 89 85,109 8,667 8,752 8,782 8,677 822 81,597 85,109 85,109 8600 85,415 8,459 83,273 878 8 84,200 84,200 852 8,700 8,827 8.83 8,667 8,782 84 8 8,990 84 8.26 8.13 8.80 8.69 8 81 892 812 8 81 8 8 85,415 8,459 83,719 8,017 8,826 8,292 82,122 8,172 816,430 814,226 85,087 83,140 86,226 | We found 58 numbers that start with the digit 9. Here they are: 95 94,608 9,661 904 9,747 9,042 9,654 9,643 968 9,944 9,013 91 9,654 9,627 9,944 9000 90,532 94,608 9.6 960 99,514 95,335 99,514 99,102 99,430 99.1 97.9 99.4 9,661 9,042 955 9 96 9.9 9 906 95 927 95 9,430 9,226 9,680 9,626 960 9,731 9,241 99.2 99.1 90.0 95 90,532 92,630 9,598 9,476 9,811 9,020 9,020 94,799 |
While the above NC 10K Filed 3/5/2025 is interesting in isolation, we have found that it is also useful to take a look at older
NACCO INDUSTRIES INC filings processed by our Benford's Law Stocks algorithm, to see how the company's filings "typically look" on a
Benford's Law analysis. Below we repeat the 10K Filed 3/5/2025 but instead of the chart comparing against the typical company across
our coverage universe, below we show the same chart compared against the typical NC 10Q and 10K filings that we have processed
historically. This is followed by similar charts for each of those historical filings.
| 10K Filed 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 1,032 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 5/1/2024 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 354 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 8/2/2023 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 471 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 11/2/2022 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 503 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10K Filed 3/2/2022 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 1,032 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 5/5/2021 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 310 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 8/5/2020 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 574 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 10/30/2024 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 583 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10K Filed 3/6/2024 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 1,020 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 5/3/2023 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 311 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 8/3/2022 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 461 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 11/3/2021 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 499 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10K Filed 3/3/2021 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 1,058 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 5/7/2020 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ❌ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 856 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 7/31/2024 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 541 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 11/1/2023 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 512 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10K Filed 3/15/2023 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 973 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 5/4/2022 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 307 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 8/4/2021 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 462 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 10Q Filed 11/2/2020 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
XBRL? ✓ [ original filing ] Total numbers found: 668 ■ = Typical NC range from 5/7/2020 to 3/5/2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||